Thank you to Rotarians Mr Larry Lavargna and Ms Elmira Gainey for co-chairing Stuart-Sunrise Rotary’s 2nd Annual Water Forum, Public Health as it Relates to the St Lucie River. There are few instances where so many influential water voices come together to speak on the river as it relates to public health and for a question/answer period after each to boot. A excellent public forum!
I noticed that of all the speakers, Dr Gary Goforth had written out his talk, thus in case you were unable to attend, I asked if he would share. His words are included below. You can also find many of the presentations recorded and posted at Treasure Coast on Facebook.
The most powerful things happen when we all get involved and include others! Thank you Sunshine-Rotary!
2019 SSRC OUR WATER 2019 Booklet
2nd Annual Rotary Water Forum – October 5, 2019
Public Health as it Relates to the River
We are so blessed to live in Paradise! Like you I love this river, its estuary, its mangroves, its beaches, its near-shore reefs. But as many of you know, it is a Paradise with a tragic problem. Below the surface of this serene river lies poison.
Ms. Sandra Thurlow recently provided the following treasure: In 1885, Homer Hine Stuart, Jr. for whom Stuart is named carried around a small woodcutting representing the confluence of the North Fork and South Fork of the St Lucie Rivers. This carving showed the river as 20 feet deep at the location of the future Roosevelt Bridge. Imagine that!
Thirty years later Ernie Lyons described looking down into the River 15-20 ft through clear tea-colored water to a sandy bottom below.
The area behind us was known worldwide as “Giant Tarpon Kingdom” with regular catches of silver kings above 175 pounds. The world record was reported as 220 pounds, caught just up river.
In 1913, the State of Florida decided to construct a canal connecting Lake Okeechobee with the Atlantic Ocean. The primary intent was to divert the overflow of Lake Okeechobee away from its natural course south through the Everglades, thereby allowing the sawgrass plains south of the lake to be developed for agriculture. A secondary benefit was to provide cross-Florida transportation of produce and other commerce.
On June 15, 1923, the first recorded discharges from Lake Okeechobee passed through the newly constructed St. Lucie Canal, which connected the St. Lucie Estuary to the Lake. But an unintended consequence was the discharge of countless tons of muck and dirty freshwater from the Lake that forever changed the landscape of the St Lucie River and Estuary.
Within 10 years the Martin County Commissioners had asked the State to stop the discharges “for the reason that the continued discharge of a large volume of dirty freshwater has killed all the shell fish, driven all salt water fish from the river, filled the river with hyacinths and so polluted the St Lucie River as to completely take away the attractive features and ruin its commercial value to the community.” (December 15, 1930 MCBCC)
The lake discharges drove out the king tarpons – the 150-200 pounders – and the small city of Stuart recast itself as the “Sailfish Capital of the World.”
Ernie Lyons described the damage in this way:
“We turned our good, sweet water into a cup of poison and changed a laughing little river into a reeking abomination – in the latter part of an ordinary lifetime. Clean rivers are not “forever and forever” like the sunrise.” (from The Last Cracker Barrel (1976) p 62)
As a professional engineer I’ve had the honor of working to protect the environment of south Florida for more than three decades – in the Everglades, in Lake Okeechobee, along the Kissimmee River and its headwaters, and in the magnificent estuaries –the St Lucie and Caloosahatchee. My wife and I raised three kids here along the St Lucie River and I’ve taught my two grandsons to fish and appreciate the incredible biological diversity throughout the river and estuary and near shore reefs. But unfortunately, we don’t eat the fish we catch in the River because of the public health risk.
- I recently had the misfortune of being in the emergency room of our local hospital. One of the very first questions I was asked was if I had had any recent contact with the St Lucie River.
- During the 2016 discharges I walked along Stuart Beach with Jacqui Thurlow-Lippisch and we collected the names and stories of over 100 people who had gotten sick after coming in contact with the water.
- A beautiful dog, Finn, died that summer after morning frolic in the water. Several other dogs suffered acute liver failure, and suffer to this day.
2016 was a watershed year in understanding the relationship between the discharge of polluted water from the Lake and public health. The media began to focus on toxic blue green algae – particularly the microcystis form. While parts of our beloved estuary were covered in foul smelling neon green guacamole, the media began reporting on the effects of microcystis and human health. An Ohio State University study reported that those of us in Martin and St Lucie County have twice the national average rate of death for non-alcoholic liver disease. They correlated this high rate with one thing – discharge of polluted water carrying blue green algae from Lake Okeechobee. This particular form of blue-green algae – microcystis – carries a dangerous toxin that can cause serious liver disease which can lead to death. Additional human health risks have also been identified – Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s and Lou Gehrig’s disease.
In the last year – thanks to the efforts of Congressman Brian Mast – the Corps of Engineers acknowledged for the first time that Lake discharges to the estuaries carrying microcystis are toxic to humans, and the US Government makes these discharges knowingly and with the understanding that they are poisoning us – the public that they serve.
Numerous public health advisories have been issued in our region in association with lake discharges – warnings to the public to avoid contact with the water. But none have ever been issued when Lake water is sent south – the environmental conditions south of the lake are not advantageous for sustaining toxic blooms. So the alternative to knowingly poisoning the public are clear – send the water south.
Col. Kelly is now in charge, and we are truly grateful for his leadership. As the Corps revises its operation schedule of the Lake, I am sure that Col. Kelly will ensure that the public health, economies and environment of our region are given equal weight as the public health, economies and environment of the area south of the Lake. Hundreds of millions of dollars in economic loss are felt by the regions around the estuaries during years of heavy lake discharges. Public health is adversely affected. There is no acceptable level of lake discharges. There is no level of Lake releases to the St Lucie Estuary that is beneficial.
Lake discharges contain pollutants include toxic blue green algae, sediment (muck), low salinity water, and nutrients. However, even if all the Lake water was sent south, our beloved St Lucie would still be in trouble. Our local watershed has its challenges – particularly high levels of nitrogen and phosphorus in agricultural runoff. Our watershed suffers from the same lack of pollution regulation as the Lake Okeechobee watershed: landowners are not held accountable for pollution from their property.
But the problem is not just ag runoff – WE ALL ARE RESPONSIBLE. For the St Lucie Estuary, approximately 5-10% of the total nitrogen loading is from our septic tanks. If you have a tank – have it inspected and maintained. Water quality data show an improvement in nitrogen levels due to positive actions taken by the City of Stuart, Martin County, Port St. Lucie and homeowners – conversion of more than 8,000 septic tanks to centralized sewer. The City of Stuart has one of the best programs for converting septic tanks to sewers: a voluntary system that allows homeowners the option of waiting until their tanks or drainfields need replacing before hooking up. But converting septic to sewer doesn’t solve the problem of nutrient overload – it just moves the problem to other areas. The majority of the residuals from wastewater treatment plants are returned to our watersheds as “biosolids” that contain high concentrations of phosphorus and nitrogen. An article in this morning’s Stuart News documented the presence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria in dolphins, and the researchers attribute much of the problem to pharmaceuticals that pass generally untreated through centralized sewers and are returned to the watershed through biosolids. We still need a better strategy for managing biosolids. Sen. Harrell – we look to you for leadership in the Legislature to require additional oversight and regulation of the application of all biosolids in our watershed.
The Florida Legislature is the single most influential group that can positively affect the public health in the state of Florida. The Legislature has an obligation to understand that allowing continued pollution of Lake Okeechobee and the estuaries will directly and adversely impact the health of the public you represent. Unless the State begins holding landowners accountable for the pollution they generate, there is absolutely no reason to believe that our water quality will improve and as a result, our public health will continue to decline. No matter if the Corps and SFWMD implement all the projects on the books – there will still be Lake discharges of toxic water to our estuaries – and unless the Legislature reverses its direction, the water quality and public health problems will persist.
I ask Sen. Harrell to work with the Legislature to hold the state’s Dept. of Environmental Protection (DEP) accountable for protecting our environment. Their current program for improving water quality going into the Lake is terribly broken. Pollution loading to the lake reached an all-time high in 2017. And compounding this problem is that annual DEP reports to the Governor and legislature and public are misleading – as they allege that pollution loads are decreasing – when the reality – as documented by the SFWMD – is that average pollution loads are higher than the Starting Period. For 2017 the measured phosphorus loads to the Lake were 60% greater than they reported in their annual report. For 2018, the measured loads were 40% greater than they reported. Who holds the DEP accountable for transparency and accuracy in reporting to the Governor, the Legislature and the public? Sen. Harrell – please demand accountability on the part of DEP.
USEPA recently established draft guidelines for microcystin in water. We urge the legislature to direct DEP to expeditiously embrace and adopt those guidelines to protect human health. We support Col. Kelly’s efforts to prevent Lake discharges to our estuary that contain blue green algae, and urge him to adopt the microcystin guideline into the new version of the Lake operating manual.
I want to thank Ms. Thurlow-Lippisch on behalf of the SFWMD – for exploring more ways to sending Lake water south through the STAs, into the Everglades and on to Florida Bay. The SFWMD is also the agency responsible for collecting water quality data documenting the state of the water. Thanks to the leadership of Ms. Thurlow-Lippisch, they are initiating steps to establish a regulatory program that if done properly will hold landowners accountable for reducing nutrient pollution. The SFWMD will need our support as they develop an effective program – and we the public need to turn out and support them in their efforts.
We’ve heard Col. Kelly and others describe projects to be completed in the next 2-3 years. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the first discharges from the Lake with a promise to stop the toxic discharges?!
I’d like to end with a challenge for all of us from an idol of mine – Timer Powers – Timer was a former Martin County commissioner and water management board member and Executive Director:
“The greatest challenge in front of us is to take the steps that are necessary to assure that our younger generation has the rivers, the creeks and the critters that are at the heart of our whole society. There’s not many people representing the critters, and if we fail to represent those who can’t represent themselves, either nature or people, then we have failed.”
So to my fellow clean water advocates – let’s rise up to meet this challenge! We can do this people!
Thank you all, and to the Rotary for bringing us all together on this beautiful day along side this beautiful estuary!
17 thoughts on “Sunrise Rotary’s 2nd Annual Water Forum, Public Health as it Relates to the River”
On Saturday, I wished everyone I loved could have been sitting on the Stuart Riverwalk Stage benches during the Rotary’s Water Forum. Thank you Jacqui for what you have shared.
Thank you Jacqui for this post! Many of use use Dr. Gary Goforth’s data that 88% of the nutrients coming into and out of Lake O. are from agricultural runoff. You personally, the SFWMD & the USACE have a very difficult job with the EAA lobby pushing our FL Legislature & the courts to keep Lake O. levels high. The EAA lobby, Lake O Alliance, etc. continue to ignore the adverse human health and marine health impact of discharging any cyanobacteria (Microcystis aeruginosa) laden water to the East Coast & West Coast.
Thank you for this information on “How It Happened” I hope many of the uninformed will study the remarks from Dr Goforth talk and get behind your effort to clean up the swamp??
I just came back from a little fishing pier on the west shore of the lagoon—just south of pineda causeway. I was catching catfish after catfish(unedable kind) then I heard a BOOM. On the other side of the lagoon(1 1/2 miles away) there was now a small black smoke fire. About 5 minutes later the first police car. Another 4 minutes another boom and the fire then got big.. It is hard to unbuckle your seat belt when you are hanging from it so I imagine it was at least 8 minutes before the driver actually burned to death. I feel a little guilty because I have foam(the right kind) of fire exstinguishers in my truck. Not near as guiltuy as you guys should feel spending all your time lieing on people who have septic tanks instead of spending 100$ so policemen can have foam fire exstinguishers. The passers by got some really good vidio if you want to look it. Whats it going to take for you lieing basterds to pull your head out.
The rivers being deep plays into what I have been saying—rivers never have been a permanit feature in our lagoon. Manitees going in and pooping —organic marteial being preserved in acid eventually damed them up and calcium carbonate 10-20 foot down would turn to liquid and then a new river form when the land “slide” and blew out.
We now have lots of monster tarpin here
Haveing been a welder for 40 years I know how a well aimed fire exstinguisher can stop a whole lot of drama. A AB foam can bring a car fire with 40 foot flames down to nothing in 5 seconds. Anomous is me—Brent
Thank you for posting Gary’s words….he is a true expert and knows all of the facts and could have solved this problem years ago if not for the interference of the sugar industry and some politicians who would never listen to the scientists. Glad that the Rotary Club has come forward after all these years, we need everyone involved.
Jackie I allow all comments and I think I know who most are with no names. Try not to censor in anyway. Yes people should use names in best case. Thanks for your comments and letting us know it’s YOU. 🙂
You should really stop posting from anyone who refuses to give name.
Listen to the science–Not the scientest-Every corporation and special interest has its scientest who will snowball everone to believing only THEY have all the facts. My name is Brent Wohlenberg and the commints are mine.
Kidde 466620 class AB foam is the right fire exstinguisher for the job. Spray the wrong one in a confined space and you could suffacat someone.There is very little nitrogen gas in this one.
Keep up the good job work!!
Front page of the Vero Beach paper reads—Tsunami Brewing over posioning of Florida Lakes .It gave a list of 16 differant poisons being sprayed. Decade after decade of spraying and it is all still there —-being preserved in zero oxygen–acid environment. Just waiting to be activated. The paper gave list of 16 posions they have been spraying in 32,000 lakes. You add this to posioning our Nation with aluminum sulfate (that causes alzhimers)in biosolids on farmland and pumping sewage underground and the worst that will happen to them is THEY MIGHT GET FIRED.
Here waves bring pee and poop (amonia and HCL ) to shore where they churn in calcium carbonate shell and sand. CO2 foam goes into the air and desolved oxygen into the water—speeding up the reaction between the ammonia and HCL makeing calcium cloride salt. This chemistry makes wonderfull sea grass flats. Same chemistry goes on in septic tanks makeing dark green healthy yard. State gov. has been blameing and extorting money from septic tank owners for years. Now it looks like Mr Goforth (who works for state gov.)is going be pointing his finger and extorting money from farmers as well. There is nothing cute about this.
Are you in the Sunrise Rotary? I was in one of the same name here but didn’t want to get up so early.
Hi Aunt Sanna! I am not in Sunsrise Rotary, but have many friends who like to get up that early!!! Love to you! Jacqui